My friend James, a newspaper man of the Walter Burns variety (think Walter Matthau, not Cary Grant), is always sternly telling me how the Internet, blogs, RSS feeds and the modern world in general are killing newspapers, and when they’re dead and gone we’ll all be sorry because there will be no more editors, lawyers, and large corporations checking that their greedy, vested, corporate interests will be respected facts are straight, and there will be no more investigative journalism, breaking stories (more commonly known as sifting through celebrities’ bin bags), or reliable sources of information (because everything on the internet was just, you know, made up).
Well it seems that he may not have been overstating his case. On Saturday (otherwise known as April Fools’ Day), the fairly well-known movie news site JoBlo posted an April Fools’ joke that Kate Beckinsale had been cast as Wonder Woman in the forthcoming Joss Whedon movie. Now there were certain tell-tale signs that the story was a joke (not least that Whedonites, the most terrifying fandom on the planet, would have burnt cinemas to the ground before watching Kate Beckinsale butchering Whedon’s dialogue): such as quoting Whedon—a well-known feminist—talking about actresses offering to “blow him” for the part, or that Beckinsale was obviously going to have to have a “boob job”. But perhaps the biggest give away was the article ending thusly:
Whedon […] said that he would even take part in the site’s annual April Fool’s Day gag this year, which was a nice thing of him to do, especially since that’s what you’ve been reading this entire article. That’s right, every word is untrue, folks … gotta love the Internet!
Now I’m the first to admit that it wasn’t the funniest April Fools’ joke I’ve ever seen. But it was fairly obvious to anyone with half a brain that that’s what it was. But that didn’t stop those geniuses at World Entertainment News Network carrying the story as fact. One of the most notable subscribers of WENN’s news feed is The Internet Movie Database who carried the story, and from there on hundreds if not thousands of sites carried the story too, either directly from WENN or via IMDb. And like Chinese whispers, as the story was reprinted it became more and more detached from any semblance of truth and factuality. For example, InTheNews.co.uk printed this:
English beauty Kate Beckinsale is said to be fronting the race to be appointed the lead actress in the new Wonder Woman flick.
Director Joss Whedon and co-writer William M Marston, director of the 1976 original, are believed to have been impressed after meeting the British babe and could be about to offer her the role.
Beckinsale, star of Van Helsing and Underworld, has also recently reaffirmed her desire to land the part in the upcoming comic book movie.
“I want Wonder Woman right now,” she said. “I’m not holding my breath, but I’m crossing my fingers and toes and praying.”
As Simon on Whedonesque pointed out, William Marston (the original creator of Wonder Woman) died in 1947, so I don’t think he was directing much in 1976, and certainly wasn’t going to be having much of a say in the casting of the new movie, and the quote about “crossing my fingers and toes and praying” was actually said by Charisma Carpenter.
So, this is a sorry state of affairs. But the Internet giveth and the Internet taketh away. Just as sites were regurgitating this without bothering to check any original sources, and in some cases adding a few extra falsehoods of their own, those brave souls at Whedonesque charged in with the sword of truthiness, and JoBlo issued a statement. Meanwhile, the story continues to be reprinted around the Internet. And, only a day late, quick on the uptake as ever, has finally made it’s way into the UK press, still equally devoid of fact. Congratulations, The Sun! (What was that you were saying about newspapers vs. the Internet, James?)